Home > Fact Sheets > Faith and Freedom > Did America Create Slavery?

Fact Sheet | Faith and Freedom

Did America Create Slavery?

An honest look at an old evil, and why the whole story matters

Picture a kitchen table on a school night. Your son or daughter looks up from a history assignment and asks a hard question: "Did America invent slavery?"

It's a fair question, and it deserves a careful answer. Slavery is one of the darkest chapters in the human story. Real men, women and children were bought and sold, worked without pay, and torn away from the people they loved, including here on American soil. Any honest answer has to start there, with sorrow and not with excuses.

But an honest answer also has to tell the whole story, and that's what the article below sets out to do.

The article argues that slavery is far older than America and has stained nearly every part of the world. It points to ancient Greece and Rome, to Israel's bondage in Egypt in the book of Exodus, to slave trades across Africa and into the Middle East, and to slavery among native peoples of the Americas long before Columbus. It also notes that slavery has not ended, and that millions of people are held in it around the world today. It asks readers to weigh all of that history before answering the question in the title.

The article is published by WallBuilders and carries no individual byline. AFA of Indiana is sharing it in full. It's worth reading slowly, and worth passing along.

Where newer research adds context, you'll find a short editor's note at the end.

Democratic Senator Tim Kaine announced on the floor of the Senate that:

For even the most basic student of world history such a statement ought to immediately be recognized as incomprehensively ridiculous. Historically, every single people, nation, culture, and race has at various times been both the slave and the master. Indeed, “all have sinned and fallen short” (Romans 3:23). Sen. Kaine, just like the famously inaccurate 1619 Project, must ignore documented history and create his own fantasy world to arrive at such a conclusion.

For example, in ancient Greece—which existed thousands of years before America—nearly 30% of their population were slaves. The Roman Empire reached a staggering 40%.2 In fact, one of the most significant and widely known aspects of the Bible centers around the Israelites being delivered out of slavery in Egypt through the famous Exodus. We could walk through every nation in human history and find a tragic past riddled with slavery.

Arab Slavers

Prior to the creation of the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade by the Spanish from Africa to South America in the early 1500s, Africa already participated in a robust trans-Saharan and Indian Ocean slave trade. Black tribes would raid, capture, and enslave other black tribes for profit, selling them across the continent and beyond. Many of these slaves were sold into the Islamic Middle East, and “medieval Arabs came to associate the most degrading forms of labor with black slaves.”3 Most likely it was this racial bias which was translated to the Iberian Peninsula (i.e., Spain and Portugal) when the Muslims conquered parts of that area in the 8th century. When the Spanish became the first European nation to significantly colonize the New World, they seemingly brought this bias with them which was thereby disseminated through the Americas, North, Central, and South. In this sense, America very literally inherited racial slavery—from the Arab Middle East through Spain.

Christian Slaves

What is perhaps even more astounding is that a larger number of white Europeans were captured and sold into African slavery than the number of Africans sold into the land that would become the United States. Just over 300,000 black slaves landed in the North American colonies which became America4 but 1,250,000 white Europeans were captured and shipped to slave markets in Northern Africa.5 This Barbary Coast Trade lasted longer than American slavery and was only stopped through the naval efforts of the British and Americans. Furthermore, it was not until the late 17th century that black slaves in the New World outnumbered white slaves in the Old.6

Additionally, for hundreds of years before Christopher Columbus ever conceived of the idea to sail westward, the Native Americans practiced mass slavery amid other practices including human sacrifice and cannibalism. This pre-Columbian native slave trade was so prolific that “wherever European conquistadors set foot in American tropics, they found evidence of indigenous warfare, war captives, and captive slaves.”7 Indeed, indigenous cultures saw slavery rates so prevalent that up to 20-40% of all Indians were enslaved by other Indians.8

Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade

Even today, nearly 160 years after America became one of the first nations to abolish slavery, there are still 94 nations that do not have laws criminalizing slavery.9 This has led to the enslavement of over 40 million people in the world right now. In a stroke of tragic irony, Africa has the highest rate of slavery today, closely followed by Asia,10 while North America has the lowest.11 Currently, Africa holds some 9,240,000 people in chains and slavery today,12 which is nearly identical to the total number of slaves disembarked in the entire New World (North, Central, and South America) throughout the almost four centuries of the Trans-Atlantic slave trade.13

So, clearly Sen. Tim Kaine must either be completely ignorant about the history of slavery or maliciously intentional in his presentation of “facts.” America in no way created slavery—in fact, if we were to say anyone “created” slavery in America we must conclude that the indigenous people did so. By contrast, the United States, despite its well-known shortcomings, ought to receive credit for having done more than nearly any other nation in the history of the world to fight slavery both in the past and today.

Originally published by WallBuilders.

[Editor's note: Several Northern states abolished slavery in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, but the nation as a whole abolished it in 1865, when the 13th Amendment was ratified (National Archives). Slave Voyages estimates that about 10.5 million enslaved Africans landed in the Americas, and that about 388,000 landed in mainland North America (Slave Voyages Estimates).]

Footnotes

  1. Tobias Hoonhout, “Dem Sen. Kaine Claims United States ‘Created’ Slavery and ‘Didn’t Inherit Slavery from Anybody,’” National Review, June 16, 2020. ↩
  2. Fernando Santos-Granero, Vital Enemies: Slavery, Predation, and the Amerindian Political Economy of Life (Austin: University of Texas Press, 2009), 226-227. ↩
  3. Philip Morgan, “Origins of American Slavery,” Organization of American History Magazine of History (July 2005), 19:4:53. ↩
  4. “Summary Statistics,” Slave Voyages, accessed June 16, 2020. Summary Statistics with the Principle Place of Slave Landing being restricted to Rhode Island, Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, the Gulf Coast, and “Other North America.” ↩
  5. Past & Present (Aug., 2001), No. 172, 118, Robert C. Davis, “Counting European Slaves on the Barbary Coast”; Robert C. Davis, Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters: White Slavery in the Mediterranean, the Barbary Coast, and Italy, 1500-1800 (NY: Palgrave MacMillan, 2004), 23-24. ↩
  6. Morgan, “Origins of American Slavery,” American History Magazine (July 2005), 19:4:53. ↩
  7. Santos-Granero, Vital Enemiese (2009), 1. ↩
  8. Santos-Granero, Vital Enemies (2009), 226-227. ↩
  9. Sonia Elks, “Slavery is Not a Crime for Almost Half the Countries in the World,” Reuters (February 12, 2020), accessed June 16, 2020. ↩
  10. “Prevalence Across the Regions,” Global Slavery Index (2018), accessed June 16, 2020, here. ↩
  11. “Regional Highlights: Americas,” Global Slavery Index (2018), accessed June 17, 2020, here. ↩
  12. “Region Highlights: Africa,” Global Slavery Index (2018), accessed June 16, 2020, here. ↩
  13. “Summary Statistics,” Slave Voyages, accessed June 16, 2020. ↩

Why this matters

Slavery was never a small sin. It treats a person made by God as a thing to be owned. Scripture tells us where every person's worth comes from:

That truth is why slavery was always wrong, in every century and on every continent, including our own. It's also why Christians can't look away from the millions who are still enslaved today.

The question of who "created" slavery matters because our children are learning to see their country, and themselves, through the stories they're told. If they hear only that America invented this evil, they miss how widespread the sin of slavery has been in the human heart. If they hear only that others did it too, they miss the real suffering that happened here. Our kids need both: the grief and the gratitude for those who fought to end it.

The article itself reaches for a verse that belongs at the center of this conversation:

No nation is innocent, and no people is beyond the reach of God's mercy. Here in Indiana, let's teach our children history with open eyes and soft hearts.

Want a copy to share or study? Download the printable AFA of Indiana fact sheet, "Did America Create Slavery?"

Get the printable fact sheet

Print it, share it, hand it out.

Download the PDF (2 pages, 251 KB)

More on Faith and Freedom

< Back to Faith and Freedom

Take action

Get the AFA of Indiana Insider Email, find your state legislator, or support this work.

American Family Association of Indiana
P.O. Box 219, Noblesville, IN 46061
317-257-7221