Home > Fact Sheets > Faith and Freedom > They Can't All Be True

Fact Sheet | Faith and Freedom

They Can't All Be True

Many faiths can share a street. They cannot all share the truth.

You've seen the sticker. Maybe it was on the car ahead of you at a red light, or on a laptop in a coffee shop. It spells COEXIST with symbols of different faiths and beliefs, lined up side by side like old friends.

The message sounds gentle, and part of it is right. Christians are called to love their neighbors, to live peaceably, and to treat people of every faith with kindness and respect. Nobody needs a bumper sticker to tell us that.

But a lot of people read something more into that row of symbols. They take it to mean that all religions are really the same underneath, that they're just different paths up the same mountain, so it doesn't much matter which one you choose. Once a person settles there, the big questions stop feeling urgent. Be nice, follow your heart, and leave it at that.

Is that true? Can every faith be right at the same time?

Al Serrato tackles that question in the article below, first published at CrossExamined.org on June 26, 2021. He starts somewhere you might not expect, with a fingerprint left at a crime scene and the careful work it takes to find the one person who left it. From there he shows why a quick glance at the world's religions isn't enough, and why the question deserves a closer look.

AFA of Indiana is sharing his article in full. It's worth reading slowly, and worth passing along.

Every year in America, thousands of crimes occur in which there are no witnesses and very little evidence. Sometimes, the perpetrator leaves behind a fingerprint impression – a latent print -somewhere at the crime scene. In the past, these prints possessed little value in identifying the offender; before a comparison could be conducted, the police would have to already have a known suspect.

Today, law enforcement officers have access to much better technology, in the form of AFIS – the Automated Fingerprint Identification System. Maintained by the FBI, it houses the data for millions of fingerprint impressions, allowing an unknown latent print to be compared to millions of known offenders. In a matter of minutes, the AFIS computer can spit out the top twenty possible matches to the unknown latent print. But this is only the beginning of the analysis because, with only one latent print at the scene, there is but one actual source for the print. A trained analyst must then spend the time examining in fine detail the patterns of each suspect – the whorls and arches and loops, the ridges and furrows – to determine whether an exact match can be made. The top twenty possible matches have much in common, but on further examination, differences will emerge in the ridge pattern and detail until the one actual source can be identified.

So, what does this have to do with the field of apologetics? Just this: living as we are in very pluralistic times, we often encounter people who believe that all religions are basically the same. Examining them superficially, they will see that religions share a number of features; for example, most teach the utility of treating others with respect, of being kind, of helping the poor. So, while acknowledging some differences in doctrines, people who hold this view believe they have arrived at a great truth: there is no one right religion, just people who mistakenly, and sometimes dangerously, think that they have the corner on truth. This leaves them feeling settled, for the moment, as they conclude that no further inquiry is required. Just be kind to others and follow your heart and all will be well. But on closer examination, all they have really done is stopped searching for the truth, for the “source” of the life that has been given to them and the universe that surrounds them.

Like fingerprints, religions can appear on the surface to be identical, or nearly so, when in fact they are not. And to determine where and how they differ requires a rigorous and close inspection. This of course is crucial in a fingerprint analysis because we know that for one print, there can only be one source. No analyst would stop when she narrowed the search to three possible sources because common sense and reason dictate that two of the three – or perhaps all three – must also be excludable on further inquiry. It is the nature of the thing examined.

So too with the knowledge of God. The major world religions make mutually exclusive truth claims about the nature and attributes of God. Do we live and die once, and then face judgment, as Christianity teaches? Or do we undergo a continuous cycle of life, death, and reincarnation? Is there one God consisting of three persons, or are there instead of a single god or a multitude of deities? For one religion to be true, the others cannot be.

It is logically possible, of course, that all religions are false. It is not possible, by contrast, for religions holding contrary positions to all be true. Either Jesus Christ is the Son of God who rose from the dead and thereby provides salvation to a fallen world, as Christians claim, or he is not. He cannot be both savior and mere sage at the same time.

Critical and careful analysis of a latent fingerprint can lead to the discovery of the truth as to who left it behind. Making the effort is critical to the pursuit of justice, the importance of which we all intuitively recognize.

But critical and careful analysis can also lead to knowledge of the one God who brought us into existence. When we fail to investigate this question because we mistakenly believe that we already know all we need to know – that is, when we allow ourselves to be misled to believe that all religions are pretty much the same – we may not intuitively realize just how much we are giving up.

After all, what comes next – what awaits each of us at the end of our days here on Earth – is without a doubt the most important question that we must confront. And the sooner we begin that process, the sooner we will find that good and satisfying answers await.

By Al Serrato, June 26, 2021, originally published at CrossExamined.org

Why this matters

Being kind to people who believe differently is right. Pretending every belief is the same is not kindness. It just quietly stops the search for the truth.

This isn't only a debate for scholars. It's a question that comes home. It shows up at the dinner table when a teenager asks why your family believes what it believes. It comes up in a dorm room, at work, or at a funeral, when someone wonders what comes next. If our kids grow up hearing that all religions are basically the same, why would they ever look closely at the claims of Jesus Christ?

Christians don't need to be afraid of that closer look. Jesus did not offer Himself as one good option among many. He said:

That's a claim that has to be weighed, not one that can be blended in with the others. We can live alongside our neighbors in peace and still tell them, with gentleness, that truth is worth finding.

So the next time you see that sticker, let it remind you of the question underneath it, and be ready to talk about it with your family, your church, and your neighbors here in Indiana.

Want a copy to share? Download the printable AFA of Indiana fact sheet, "They Can't All Be True."

Get the printable fact sheet

Print it, share it, hand it out.

Download the PDF (2 pages, 89 KB)

More on Faith and Freedom

< Back to Faith and Freedom

Take action

Get the AFA of Indiana Insider Email, find your state legislator, or support this work.

American Family Association of Indiana
P.O. Box 219, Noblesville, IN 46061
317-257-7221