Home > Fact Sheets > Sexuality & Gender > Who's The Victim Now?
Fact Sheet | Sexuality & Gender
Who's the Victim Now?
Religious liberty, real pain on every side, and how to stand firm with grace
Picture a woman who runs a small business out of her home. She is not a real client or a court case, only a way to put a face on a question many Hoosiers carry. She loves her customers, all of them. Lately she lies awake wondering: if someone asks her to create something that goes against her faith, and she politely says no, what happens next?
Many Hoosier Christians carry that question. They don't want a fight. They want to live and work by what they believe, and to treat everyone with kindness while they do.
Pain is real on every side
LGBTQ people have suffered real harm. On June 12, 2016, 49 people were killed at Pulse, a gay nightclub in Orlando. That was a horror, and every Christian should grieve it.
Admitting that pain doesn't weaken the case for religious liberty.
A strategy written down in 1987
In November 1987, Marshall Kirk and Hunter Madsen published an essay in Guide magazine called "The Overhauling of Straight America." The byline was Marshall Kirk and Erastes Pill, Madsen's pen name. They laid out a public-relations plan:
Two years later they expanded the essay into a book. Whatever you think of their goals, the plan was clear: shape the story around who gets seen as the victim.
Indiana remembers 2015
Hoosiers saw how that story can play out. Indiana's Religious Freedom Restoration Act, SB 101, was signed on March 26, 2015. After a national backlash, a "fix," SEA 50, was signed on April 2, 2015.
Today Indiana has no statewide law on this. But for sexual orientation, 19 cities and 4 counties bar discrimination in private employment, housing and public accommodations, and 29 more localities do so in part.
When conviction costs something
People of faith have paid for their convictions.
In December 2013, A&E suspended Phil Robertson over a GQ interview, then lifted the suspension after nine days. In May 2014, HGTV canceled the Benham brothers' show, Flip It Forward, before it aired. In September 2015, Kentucky clerk Kim Davis was jailed for about five days for contempt of a federal court order. A jury later awarded $100,000 in damages, plus $260,084.70 in fees and costs, and the Supreme Court declined to hear her appeal on November 10, 2025.
In 303 Creative v. Elenis, decided 6-3 on June 30, 2023, the Supreme Court ruled that a state can't force a website designer to create expressive work that violates her beliefs.
The day it turned violent
On August 15, 2012, Floyd Lee Corkins II walked into the Family Research Council in Washington, D.C., "with the intention of shooting and killing as many employees of the organization as he could." In the statement of offense he signed, he "targeted the Family Research Council because of its views, including its advocacy against recognition of gay marriage."
An unarmed security guard, Leo Johnson, was shot in the arm and still disarmed him. Corkins pleaded guilty to committing an act of terrorism while armed, among other charges, and was sentenced to 25 years in prison. Johnson later said, "I forgive you but I do not forget."
That's a picture worth keeping: courage and forgiveness, side by side.
Where Americans stand
Gallup found that 65 percent of Americans support legal same-sex marriage, below the peak of 71 percent in 2022 and 2023.
Why this matters
Religious liberty isn't a weapon against our neighbors. It's a protection for everyone's conscience, including people who disagree with us.
Our LGBTQ neighbors aren't our enemies. Many have been hurt, and they deserve kindness and respect. At the same time, a business owner like the one in that opening scene deserves the freedom to live by her faith.
So we can do both. We can grieve with those who grieve, speak up for conscience, and answer hostility the way Leo Johnson did: firm, honest and forgiving. Here in Indiana, may we be known for that kind of courage.
Want a copy to share or study? Download the printable AFA of Indiana fact sheet, "Who's the Victim Now?"
Get the printable fact sheet
Print it, share it, hand it out.
Download the PDF (2 pages, 70 KB)More on Sexuality & Gender
Take action
Get the AFA of Indiana Insider Email, find your state legislator, or support this work.
American Family Association of Indiana
P.O. Box 219, Noblesville, IN 46061
317-257-7221