Home > Fact Sheets > Life, Marriage & Family > 5 Reasons to Oppose Assisted Suicide
Fact Sheet | Life, Marriage & Family
5 Reasons to Oppose Assisted Suicide
Why caring for the dying means staying beside them, not hurrying them along
Picture a hospital room late at night. Someone you love is very sick. The machines hum, the hallway is quiet, and you're sitting in a plastic chair holding a hand that feels thinner than it used to. Maybe they're in pain. Maybe they're scared. Maybe they've said the words that break a family's heart: "I don't want to be a burden."
Most of us have sat in that chair, or we will someday. And in that room, the most important question isn't a legal one. It's a human one: what does love do now?
A growing number of voices say love should offer a way out. They call it assisted suicide, or "assisted death," and they describe it as compassion and choice. The article below takes a hard look at that claim.
It gives five reasons to oppose assisted suicide. It says these laws involve causing a person's death. It argues that the "safeguards" written into them protect the doctors who take part, not the vulnerable people who die. It says assisted death goes against a physician's calling as a healer. It points out that doctors are human, and that a wrong diagnosis can't be corrected once a life is over. And it warns that what begins as a choice can turn into pressure, on doctors and on patients. Along the way it shares the account of a mother who stood up to a doctor after he raised assisted death as an option for her daughter, and it closes with a call for "caring, not killing."
The article comes from the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition (epcc.ca), which published it in June 2020 as "Five Reasons to Oppose Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide." AFA of Indiana is sharing it in full.
Where newer information adds context, you'll find a short editor's note from AFA of Indiana at the end.
There are many reasons to oppose euthanasia and assisted suicide (also known as assisted death). Here we focus on five key reasons.
1 Assisted death should be opposed because it involves causing a person’s death (killing).
Laws permitting assisted death give doctors (and nurse practitioners in Canada) the right to cause a person’s death. Society should never allow one person to legally kill another.
In Canada, the Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg, assisted death is done by euthanasia. Euthanasia is intentionally injecting a person with a combination of lethal drugs. In most countries it is prohibited under murder or homicide laws.
In the United States and Switzerland, assisted death is done by assisting a person’s suicide. This is when a doctor prescribes a combination of lethal drugs that the person self-ingests.
Euthanasia and assisted suicide involve another person, usually a doctor, who directly kills or is involved with causing the death of another person.
Those who promote assisted death focus on the difficult life conditions that pressure someone to request to die. They argue from a situational ethics’ standpoint to justify killing, an act which is normally considered to be universally wrong.
Assisted death is sold as healthcare. In an interview, psychiatrist and ethicist Mark Komrad said:
People go through difficult physical or psychological conditions, but these human experiences must not be exploited to justify killing. Providing proper care and support is the appropriate response.
2 Assisted death should be opposed because “safeguards” only protect the physician; they do not protect vulnerable people.
Assisted death laws are designed to protect the physician (or another) who is willing to participate. These laws do not provide effective oversight and protection for the person who is being killed. These “safeguards” are designed to sell the legalization of assisted death to politicians who have concerns about killing, but they include exceptions that are wide enough to drive a hearse through.
The State of Oregon was the first jurisdiction to legalize assisted death in 1997.2 The assisted suicide lobby did not challenge the safeguards in the law because they wanted to convince other jurisdictions that there is no “slippery slope”. However, in 2019, the assisted suicide lobby announced that the problem with assisted suicide laws is the restrictions. That year the Oregon legislature removed the 15-day waiting period.3
The euthanasia lobby alleges that the Netherlands have not changed their euthanasia law since it was passed in 2002. This is inaccurate: the language of the Netherlands’ euthanasia law has not changed but the interpretation of the law has. The most recent example is the extension of euthanasia to include incompetent people with dementia.4
Canada is a prime example of a country where safeguards lack effective definition or meaning. For instance, Canada’s euthanasia law required that a person’s “natural death be reasonably foreseeable”. However, the meaning of this phrase was not defined5 and, consequently, the application of the law varied. In September 2019, a Québec Superior Court decision struck this phrase from the law.6
Canada is also a prime example of how a euthanasia law can incrementally expand. Canada passed its assisted death law in June 2016. In February 2020, Parliament introduced Bill C-7 to expand the law by eliminating the waiting period, permitting euthanasia of an incompetent person who requested an assisted death in advance, and eliminating the terminal illness requirement.7
Safeguards in assisted death laws are designed to politically sell killing. These laws protect physicians who are willing to kill; they do not protect those who die from the lethal drugs.
3 Assisted death should be opposed because it is fundamentally incompatible with the physician’s role as healer.
The American Medical Association Code of Ethics Opinion 5.7 (Physician-Assisted Suicide) states that:
Assisted death laws are designed to protect physicians who are willing to cause the death of a patient, usually upon request. When the role of a physician changes from healer to killer, it fundamentally changes the physician.
In August 2016, 25-year-old Candice Lewis, who had several medical conditions, was pressured by a doctor to “request” an assisted death while she was in the hospital. Candice’s mother Sheila Elson stated in a CBC News story:
Sheila said the following in the film Fatal Flaws:
The fact that Candice was a person with disabilities should not change the value of her life. How many people are pressured by a medical professional and, unlike Candice, die by assisted death?
4 Assisted death should be opposed because doctors are fallible; they can make medical errors and misdiagnose conditions.
In his article, “Why Getting Medically Misdiagnosed Is More Common Than You May Think,” Brian Mastroianni states that 12 million Americans are affected by medical diagnostic errors each year and an estimated 40,000 to 80,000 people die annually from complications related to misdiagnoses, with a similar number of people experiencing a permanent disability related to misdiagnosis.11
In April 2013, Pietro D’Amico, a 62-year-old magistrate from Calabria, Italy, died by assisted suicide at a Swiss assisted suicide clinic. His autopsy revealed that he had been medically misdiagnosed.12
Assisted death is a permanent decision often done when a person fears a painful or difficult death or is experiencing depression or feelings of hopelessness. Once they are dead, it is too late to learn that they were misdiagnosed or living with a treatable condition.
5 Assisted death laws should be opposed because legalization pressures physicians who then pressure patients.
What begins as a choice to kill or a choice to die becomes a pressure to kill and a pressure to die.
During the debate to legalize euthanasia in Canada, the euthanasia lobby argued that the issue was about choice. The “freedom of choice”: to die by euthanasia, and for a doctor or nurse practitioner to participate.
Sadly, Candice Lewis’ story may not be rare.
In February 2018, less than two years after Canada legalized assisted death, the Delta Hospice Society (DHS), an independent charitable organization in British Columbia (BC), was ordered by the Fraser Health Authority (FHA) to provide euthanasia.13 The DHS resisted and continued its good work. In December 2019, the FHA ordered them to provide euthanasia or lose their government funding.14 The DHS refused to comply with the government’s edict saying that, “MAiD is not compatible with the DHS’s purposes stated in the society’s constitution, and therefore, will not be performed at the Irene Thomas Hospice.”15
The Canadian Hospice Palliative Care Association and the Canadian Society of Palliative Physicians sent the BC Minister of Health a joint statement saying, “…MAiD is not part of hospice palliative care; it is not an ‘extension’ of palliative care nor is it one of the tools ‘in the palliative care basket’”16 The Minister of Health responded by ordering the DHS to comply or be taken over by the province in February 2021.17
Some recent assisted suicide bills in the United States have included a “do or refer” provision.18 This means that if assisted suicide is legalized, a doctor would not have to prescribe assisted suicide drugs; however, if they received a request for assisted suicide, they would be required to refer the patient to someone who will write the prescription.
In Canada, doctors in Ontario have been ordered by the College of Physicians and Surgeons to do an “effective referral”. This means that the College can punish doctors who refuse to kill and refuse to refer their patients to a doctor who will kill.19
Advocates of assisted death use the term “freedom of choice” to promote their ideology. This campaign slogan has resulted in medically condoned killing. This ideology has led to a persuasive pressure to die or an edict to kill and is the central part of a cultural campaign to normalize killing.
Society must maintain and build on its commitment to caring, not killing.
Originally published by the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition (epcc.ca) as “Five Reasons to Oppose Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide,” June 2020.
Editor's note (AFA of Indiana, November 2026): The Euthanasia Prevention Coalition published this article in June 2020, and some details have changed since then. Oregon voters approved the Death with Dignity Act in 1994, and it took effect in 1997 (note 2). Australia's Northern Territory legalized euthanasia in 1995, and Australia's Parliament overturned that law in March 1997 (Parliamentary Education Office). Oregon's 2019 change did not remove the 15-day waiting period. Since 2020, it can be waived for patients expected to die within 15 days; 193 patients received that exemption in 2025, and the state reported 400 deaths under the law that year (Oregon Health Authority). In Canada, Bill C-7 was reintroduced in October 2020 and took effect March 17, 2021. In 2024, 16,499 people died by MAID, 5.1% of all deaths in Canada (Health Canada). MAID for mental illness alone is scheduled to begin March 17, 2027, and Bill C-41, introduced October 27, 2026, would stop that expansion (Health Canada). In the Netherlands, 10,341 cases were reported in 2025, about 6% of all deaths, including 499 people with dementia and 174 with psychiatric conditions (RTE). Since February 2024, Dutch rules also allow ending the life of terminally ill children aged 1 to 12 (Government of the Netherlands). The article calls one group the Canadian Society of Palliative Physicians; its correct name is the Canadian Society of Palliative Care Physicians (see note 16). CBC News reported that Candice Lewis's hospital stay was in November 2016 (note 9). The Healthline article in note 11 does not give a figure for permanent disability; a 2023 Johns Hopkins-led study estimated about 371,000 deaths and 424,000 permanent disabilities from diagnostic error in the U.S. each year (BMJ Quality & Safety).
Endnotes
- Dunn, K. (Director). (2018). Fatal Flaws: Legalizing Assisted Death. DunnMedia & Entertainment. [Trailer]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89YQubAyRrI (Dr. Komrad’s statements start at 0:27) ↩
- Norman-Eady, S. (2002). Office of Legislative Research (OLR) Research Report: Oregon’s Assisted Suicide Law (Report No. 2002-R-0077). Connecticut General Assembly. https://www.cga.ct.gov/2002/rpt/2002-r-0077.htm ↩
- Callinan, K. (2019, January 1). End-of-Life option laws should avoid needless red tape. McKnight’s LTC News. https://www.mcknights.com/blogs/guest-columns/end-of-life-option-laws-need-compassion/ ↩
- Pieters, J. (2020, April 21). Euthanasia Allowed for Dementia Patients Who Gave Prior Consent: Supreme Court. Netherlands Times. https://nltimes.nl/2020/04/21/euthanasia-allowed-dementia-patients-gave-prior-consent-supreme-court ↩
- Schadenberg, A. (2016, June 17). Canadian Senate passes euthanasia bill in time for summer break. Euthanasia Prevention Coalition Blog. https://alexschadenberg.blogspot.com/2016/06/canadas-senate-passes-euthanasia-bill.html ↩
- Marin, S. (2019, September 11). A Quebec court has invalidated parts of the medical aid in dying laws. The Canadian Press. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/a-quebec-court-has-invalidated-parts-of-the-medical-aid-in-dying-laws-1.4588622 ↩
- Bill C-7, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying), First Session, Forty-third Parliament, 68-69 Elizabeth II, 2019-2020. https://www.parl.ca/DocumentViewer/en/43-1/bill/C-7/first-reading ↩
- Chapter 5: Opinions on Caring for Patients at the End of Life. American Medical Association (AMA) Code of Medical Ethics. https://www.ama-assn.org/system/files/2019-06/code-of-medical-ethics-chapter-5.pdf ↩
- Bartlett, G. (2017, July 24). Mother says doctor brought up assisted suicide option as sick daughter was within earshot. CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/doctor-suggested-assisted-suicide-daughter-mother-elson-1.4218669 ↩
- Dunn, K. (Director). (2018). Fatal Flaws Film Clip: “They wanted me to do an assisted suicide death on her.” [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB6zt43iCs8 ↩
- Mastroianni, B. (2020, February 22). Why Getting Medically Misdiagnosed Is More Common Than You May Think. Healthline. https://www.healthline.com/health-news/many-people-experience-getting-misdiagnosed ↩
- Aided suicide in question after botched diagnosis. (2013, July 11). The Local. https://www.thelocal.ch/20130711/assisted-suicide-in-question-after-botched-diagnosis ↩
- Fayerman, P. (2018, February 6). Delta hospice rebels against Fraser Health’s mandate to provide medical assistance in dying. Vancouver Sun. https://vancouversun.com/news/local-news/delta-hospice-rebels-against-fraser-healths-mandate-to-provide-medical-assistance-in-dying/ ↩
- Gyarmati, S. (2019, December 7). Fraser Health gives Delta Hospice ‘formal notice of concerns’. Delta Optimist. https://www.delta-optimist.com/news/fraser-health-gives-delta-hospice-formal-notice-of-concerns-1.24029942 ↩
- New Delta Hospice Society board reverses MAiD position. (2019, December 2). Delta Optimist. https://www.delta-optimist.com/news/new-delta-hospice-society-board-reverses-maid-position-1.24024999 ↩
- Canadian Hospice Palliative Care Association (CHPCA) and Canadian Society of Palliative Care Physicians (CSPCP) Joint Call to Action. (2019, November 27). https://www.chpca.ca/news/chpca-and-cspcp-joint-call-to-action/ (link no longer works) ↩
- Gyarmati, S. (2019, December 24). Here’s the deadline given to Delta Hospice. Delta Optimist. https://www.delta-optimist.com/news/here-s-the-deadline-given-to-delta-hospice-1.24041440 ↩
- Murphy, S. (Administrator). (2020, January 14). Indiana assisted suicide bill fails to protect objecting practitioners: Assisted suicide evolves from “assistance” to “medical care”. Protection of Conscience Project. https://www.consciencelaws.org/law/commentary/legal102.aspx ↩
- Advice to the Profession: Professional Obligations and Human Rights. The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO). https://www.cpso.on.ca/Physicians/Policies-Guidance/Policies/Professional-Obligations-and-Human-Rights/Advice-to-the-Profession-Professional-Obligations (link no longer works) ↩
Why this matters
Every person in that hospital bed was made by God and is loved by Him. Being sick, being old, or living with a disability doesn't make a life worth less. It doesn't make a person a burden to be managed. Scripture is plain:
But saying no to assisted suicide is only half of our answer. The other half is saying yes to the people who are suffering. When someone feels like a burden, the answer isn't to agree with them. It's to carry the load together:
That looks like ordinary things. Sitting in the plastic chair. Bringing a meal to the caregiver who hasn't slept. Asking the doctor about pain relief, hospice and comfort care. Praying with someone who is afraid, and reminding them they are wanted.
Christians don't have to pretend death isn't hard. We also don't have to face it alone:
Here in Indiana, let's be the kind of families, churches and neighbors who make sure no one walks that valley by themselves.
Want a copy to share or study? Download the printable AFA of Indiana fact sheet, "5 Reasons to Oppose Assisted Suicide."
Get the printable fact sheet
Print it, share it, hand it out.
Download the PDF (3 pages, 204 KB)More on Life, Marriage & Family
Why Indiana Needs Strong Marriages
Indiana's Public Policies Should Recognize the Importance of a Married Mother and a Father Fact sheetCohabitation & Marital Success
New Research On Cohabitation Before Marriage Fact sheetDivorce & Children
The Impact of Divorce on Children is Long-lasting< Back to Life, Marriage & Family
Take action
Get the AFA of Indiana Insider Email, find your state legislator, or support this work.
American Family Association of Indiana
P.O. Box 219, Noblesville, IN 46061
317-257-7221